Steward USCDI Development for Pragmatic Interoperability

Recommendation: ONC must lead an improved, evidence-based USCDI development and adoption process to ensure that an expanding set of meaningfully standardized and clinically relevant patient data elements is defined. This enhanced USCDI will serve as the common data foundation for all mandated FHIR-based APIs.

Rationale & Specifics:

  1. Evidence-Based Prioritization: The process for expanding USCDI must prioritize data elements with demonstrated, widespread real-world use cases and significant benefits for patient care, interoperability, research, or public health.
  2. Clear Functional Expectations for SDOs: When new data elements are added to USCDI, ONC should clearly articulate the functional expectations and provide illustrative examples of intended real-world usage. This high-level guidance enables ONC to work effectively with Standard Development Organizations (SDOs) to drive the downstream development of detailed, API-specific technical specifications and implementation guides (e.g., US Core FHIR profiles for single-patient access, and relevant profiles for Bulk FHIR operations).
  3. Iterative Refinement: An active feedback loop post-USCDI version release should be established to assess implementation quality and consistency across all API types, allowing for refinement of functional expectations or guidance.
  4. Conformance Testing: Certification testing for all FHIR APIs mandated to expose USCDI data must verify that the implementation of USCDI data elements aligns with the detailed specifications in relevant SDO-developed FHIR Implementation Guides (e.g., US Core), serving as a practical proxy for ensuring consistency with ONC's articulated functional expectations.

Steward USCDI Development for Pragmatic Interoperability